Xtreme Gardening Mykos alternative

One species or eighteen
Xtreme Gardening Mykos is a single fungus, Rhizophagus intraradices, in a granule you add by the tablespoon. In a 2024 University of Kansas trial, the Mykos sample tested carried a fungal plant pathogen. Our Mycorrhizal Fungi Powder carries 18 species, 9 endo and 9 ecto, and is dosed by the gram onto the roots.
Mykos is the cheaper bag by weight, but a tablespoon of it weighs about 12.5 g, so a pot takes about twice as much Mykos as ours. Per pot, ours costs less at matching pack sizes, and it covers trees that need ecto fungi.
£6.99 40 g pouch
Choose your pouch size★★★★★ Shop rated 4.95/5 from 513 reviews. Free UK delivery over £40. Dispatched in 1 to 2 working days.
- Mykos: one endomycorrhizal species. Ours: 18 species, 9 endo and 9 ecto.
- In a 2024 University of Kansas trial, an Xtreme Gardening product produced mycorrhizae in one pot in five, and the Mykos sample carried Olpidium, a fungal plant pathogen. What the trial found.
- Price per gram: Mykos 4.0p (1 kg) to 5.6p (450 g). Ours 5.5p (1 kg) to 9.2p (120 g).
- Per 4-litre pot from the 1 kg packs: ours 22p to 33p, Mykos about 50p. Mykos is dosed by the tablespoon, about 12.5 g each; ours is 1 to 1.5 g per litre of root ball.
- Trees such as oak, beech, birch and pine partner with ecto fungi. Only ours has them.
- Mykos carries OMRI and CDFA logos. Ours is vegan but not certified organic.
Price, dose and what is declared
| Dr Forest Mycorrhizal Fungi Powder | Xtreme Gardening Mykos | |
|---|---|---|
| Species | 18: 9 endo, 9 ecto | 1 endo: Rhizophagus intraradices |
| Form | Fine powder on a mineral carrier | Granular |
| Dose | 1 to 1.5 g per litre of root ball | 1 to 2 tbsp per 1 to 3 US gallon pot; 4 to 6 tbsp per 5 to 7 gallon |
| Packs | 40 g £6.99 · 120 g £10.99 · 250 g £17.99 · 1 kg £54.99 | 450 g £25.00 · 1 kg £40.00 |
| Price per gram | 5.5p to 17.5p | 4.0p to 5.6p |
Cost per pot
| Pot | Our powder | Dr Forest 1 kg, £54.99 | Mykos | Mykos 1 kg, £40.00 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 litres (1 US gallon) | 4 to 6 g | 22p to 33p | 1 tbsp, 12.5 g | 50p |
| 11 litres (3 US gallons) | 11 to 16.5 g | 60p to 91p | 2 tbsp, 25 g | £1.00 |
| 19 to 26 litres (5 to 7 US gallons) | 19 to 40 g | £1.05 to £2.19 | 4 to 6 tbsp, 50 to 75 g | £2.00 to £3.00 |
Mykos's maker gives its dose in tablespoons only. We use 12.5 g per tablespoon, the weight a retailer (Hydro Experts) gives alongside 3,750 propagules per tablespoon, which matches the 300 per gram on the label. Granules vary, so treat it as a close estimate. Mykos at 1 tbsp for a 1-gallon pot and 2 tbsp for 3 gallons, the two ends of the maker's 1 to 2 tbsp range. From the smaller packs, a 4-litre pot is 37p to 55p with our 120 g pouch and about 69p with the 450 g Mykos.
Mykos species, propagule count and rates from xtreme-gardening.com; UK prices from Holland Hydroponics, where the 100 g was out of stock. Checked 16 Nov 2026. Mykos and Xtreme Gardening are trademarks of their owner; Dr Forest is not affiliated.
What independent testing found
In 2024, researchers at the University of Kansas grew plants with commercial mycorrhizal products bought from Amazon, a DIY chain and sellers to indoor growers. Xtreme Gardening Mykos was one of five products in which the team found Olpidium, a fungal plant pathogen. An Xtreme Gardening product was also among those that produced mycorrhizae in only one pot out of five.
The same team reviewed 250 published trials of commercial products and found no mycorrhizae on the roots in 88% of them. Mycorrhizal spores are alive. Heat, damp and time on the shelf can kill them before the pack is opened, whatever count the label declares.
Source: Kansas News Service, "Soil health is big business, but KU researchers say many fungal products don't work as promised", 5 Dec 2024, reporting work by Liz Koziol and James Bever (New Phytologist, 2024; Applied Soil Ecology, 2024). The article names the one-in-five product as "Xtreme Gardening" without saying which of its products. The result is for the samples the KU team bought, not every batch.
Product by product
| Mykos use | Closest Dr Forest | Note |
|---|---|---|
| In the pot or planting hole | Mycorrhizal Fungi Powder | Dust or dip onto the roots, by the gram |
| On seed, 1 tbsp per foot of row | Mycorrhizal Fungi Powder | Mix with the seed or dust lightly into the drill |
How to switch
- Potted plants: dust 1 to 1.5 g per litre of root ball onto the sides and base of the root ball as it goes in.
- Bare-root: dip the roots in a thin slurry, or dust onto damp roots. A fruit tree takes about 5 to 10 g.
- Once, at planting. It has to touch the roots, so sprinkling it on the surface later does very little.
- Feed lightly once growth resumes, with All Purpose 4-4-4. Keep rock phosphate and bone-type meals out of the planting hole.
When to stay with Mykos
- You want the lowest price per kilo of product.
- You need OMRI listed inputs.
Our powder has no ericoid fungi, so it is not for blueberries, cranberries or rhododendrons, and it does nothing for brassicas, which do not form the partnership. Most garden soils already hold these fungi; it earns its place on new-build plots, disturbed ground and poor soil.
Common questions
Is Dr Forest the same as Mykos?
No. Mykos is a granule of one endomycorrhizal species, Rhizophagus intraradices, at a declared 300 propagules per gram. Ours is a fine powder with 18 species, 9 endo and 9 ecto, used at 1 to 1.5 g per litre of root ball.
Which is cheaper?
Per gram, Mykos: 4.0p from its 1 kg bag against 5.5p for ours. Per pot, ours. A tablespoon of Mykos weighs about 12.5 g, and a 4-litre pot takes 4 to 6 g of ours, so from the 1 kg packs that pot costs 22p to 33p with ours and about 50p with Mykos.
Does one species matter?
It depends what you plant. Rhizophagus intraradices partners with a wide range of vegetables, fruit and flowers. It does not partner with oak, beech, birch or pine, which need ecto fungi. A mixed planting is the case for a mixed product.
More: all brand alternatives · our guide to mycorrhizal fungi · Rootgrow
Ready to swap?
18 species, endo and ecto. Dust or dip the roots as you plant.
£6.99 40 g pouch
Free UK delivery over £40. Dispatched in 1 to 2 working days.
Written by Joe Barrington, Dr Forest, Stockport. Mykos prices and rates checked 16 Nov 2026; Dr Forest prices 16 Nov 2026. KU trial result from Kansas News Service, 5 Dec 2024.


